Nuckel's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[60 Frame Collab 3]

Good Basis

I think this kind of collaboration is great. It attracts a lot of people, even those who don't have the time or energy to work on a whole movie, and the result is a funny montage of the most random sequences one can think of. I really think of joining you for part 4 or 5.

SteakandKidneyPie responds:

You can join if you like. PM me so I can guide you there. I am glad you enjoyed it.

[The Hair]

My Goodness

Best scene is where the eye falls into his mouth. :D

Anybody else feeling reminded at that Ren & Stimpy episode "A Hard Day's Luck"? :)

Though the visual style doesn't really feel finalized here. And there is no replay button. Things you may want to consider for future submissions.

[Captain Planet Rampage]

If this'd be YouTube

I would be a subscriber now. Even though I would have to fear further installments of Pleasure Island which cracks me up just a tad too much, I think.

[Swimmin with the Sharks]

Wow.

One part of me likes watching Egoraptor's stuff but the other one yells: For the sake of your friggin sanity; run away!

- I'll just ignore the latter...

[Timmy's Giant Sandwich]

for your little cousin?

When I prepared for the show by reading your description where you tell this was created for your little cousin I was totaly not ready for this twist of events. I fear you a little now...

[Mortal Kombat FAILtality]

quite funny

Using the TF2 Scout's Sounds for Stryker? Neat idea. Also I like the use of Portal turret's sounds, GLaDOS' voice though doesn't fit the funny context as good. Nevertheless I'm disappointed of the Lui Kang-Collection. Could have used some some better script...

[Love4Dead]

not too innovative

Well, those sound mashups are already not a new thing anymore but this version with video is actually a fresh new drift. It should be quite a bit shorter though. If the viewer already knows the ending joke then such a long vid becomes sort of a long wait.

[Beard Ninja]

Its ok but...

The animations and choreographics are quite good but the thing is that this whole movie is nothing more than (kinda) fancy action with a heavy lack of actualy story telling or just any kind of clear depth and content. Back in the old days of stick man figure flashes (reffering to late 90s) it was considered to be sufficient as the pure animations were impressing enough but nowadays I don't want just a plain mixture of stick figures, Matrix, DBZ and the whole stuff that went into this packed with sounds from HL and others... I understand when you say that it may not have been your intention to serve my taste but as people felt it necessary to frontpage it I need to do an serious statement here and the tenor is: it could be better

[Coffee, boy!]

Holla

Haha, nettes kleine Filmchen. So viel aufwändige Animation für ein doch recht abgehobens Erlebniss. ^^ Was ist die Motivation hinter sowas? Nuja, wie man sieht hat's auch Newgrounds gefallen. Glückwunsch für's Frontpagen. Stimmen müssten jedoch lauter und klarer sein. Sind das Samples von SiW oder selbst eingesprochen?

Ciao.
Nuckel

Hildebrandt responds:

Hi,
der Soundtrack ist ursprünglich aus einem ballz.de Video (deutsche Flashseite, gibts leider nichtmehr), woher das original kommt weiß ich leider nicht :I
Freut mich, wenn's gefallen hat :)
H.

[Mummy's Boy]

needs improvement

Line smoothing and a least a slight amount of shading could have done a miracle to the visuals. The actual jumping scene doesn't come close to anything that has to do with pole vaulting. And the pole itself is roughly 1.5 meter, that is something you really could have done better... Though I like the use of well known cartoon elements and the music. The humor is okay but it takes more to really make me laugh though. For future installments work on visuals and think about doing a storyboard or something to help you create keyframes for complex animations.